Industries
Why agency employees leave and how to understand why
Creatives, planners and account teams leave for reasons beyond pay. How to run an exit conversation in an agency, spot patterns by account and act on them.
7 min readRead article
Marketing, Advertising & Creative Agencies · Advertising agencies
HR for Advertising Agencies: Pitches, Creative Teams and Client Deadlines
An advertising agency lives on pitches won and campaigns delivered to a launch date. Creative people and client servicing pull in different directions, and the best ideas are at risk when a team is exhausted by a pitch that never pays.
Not sure what you need? Tell us about your business in six short steps and we will come to the first meeting prepared.
Share your requirementsAn advertising agency sells ideas and execution to brands, and its people fall into two camps that must work together: creative teams of copywriters, art directors and designers, and client servicing and planning teams who hold the brief and the relationship. Pitches arrive with a short deadline and are mostly unpaid. Launch dates are fixed by the client's calendar and festival seasons. Success is judged by the client, the creative director and the awards table, and these rarely agree. See also HR for marketing agencies.
- Plan
- Hire
- Onboard
- Manage
- Develop
- Perform
- Engage
- Retain
- Exit
- Improve
When HR is weak in advertising agencies, you may see
- Unpaid pitches eat the same team
- Servicing and creative blame each other
- Titles do not match the work
- Festival and campaign peaks
- Interns carry real work
- Creative talent is bought by rivals
- Reviews are about taste
These are the places the people side of this kind of business tends to give way. The rest of this page works through them.
Who does the work in advertising agencies
HR here has to work for each of these groups, not only the office. The set-up below is written with all of them in mind.
- Creative directors
- Copywriters and art directors
- Client servicing and account directors
- Brand planners and strategists
- Production and traffic managers
- Media planning and buying executives
- Film, audio and print producers
- Finance and operations managers
- Interns and trainees
Where HR strains in advertising agencies
Unpaid pitches eat the same team
The people who win a pitch are the ones who then run the account, after weeks of late nights. If the pitch is lost, nothing is returned to them.
Servicing and creative blame each other
Servicing says creative is late, and creative says the brief kept changing. Without clear roles each side defends itself and the client feels it.
Titles do not match the work
A senior copywriter does a creative director's job for a year without the title or pay, then a rival offers both.
Festival and campaign peaks
Diwali, cricket seasons and product launches stack work into weeks. The rest of the year is calm and some people are underused.
Interns carry real work
Trainees finish client work on short notice, with little guidance, and leave with no path to a job.
Creative talent is bought by rivals
A strong art director is approached by competitors and clients. Without a path forward the agency learns about it on the resignation day.
Reviews are about taste
Feedback on creative work is personal and vague, so people cannot tell what to improve and managers avoid the talk.
HR topics for advertising agencies
Start with the topics that matter most here: Organisation Design; Performance Management; Compensation, Payroll and Benefits. Then work through the rest. Each topic is written for marketing, advertising and creative, not in general.
Organisation Design
Structure, reporting lines and who is allowed to decide what.
Performance Management
Goals, reviews and ratings that hold up in a conversation.
Compensation, Payroll and Benefits
Salary structure, payroll inputs and a month that closes on time.
HR Strategy and Workforce Planning
How many people, in which roles, by when — and what they will cost.
Recruitment and Talent Acquisition
Requisition to joining, the same way every time.
Onboarding and Probation
A first day that is the same for the fifth joiner as the first.
Employee Administration
Records, attendance, leave and the day-to-day HR that must simply work.
Learning and Development
Training planned from need rather than from the calendar.
Career and Succession Management
Named backups for the roles that cannot be vacant.
Employee Engagement and Experience
Communication, recognition and the conditions people actually work in.
Employee Relations
Two routes — one for complaints, one for conduct — kept separate.
Policies, Compliance and Governance
Policies a manager can apply, and obligations with owners and dates.
Health, Safety and Wellbeing
Induction, records, incident reporting and follow-through.
Retention and Attrition Management
Who leaves, when, why — and which of them mattered.
Exit and Alumni Management
Resignation to relieving letter, in a defined order.
HR Technology and Automation
Records that survive people, and approvals that do not queue.
HR Analytics and Management Reporting
A short monthly pack management actually reads.
HR Operations and Governance
An HR function that runs the same way every month.
What a working HR set-up looks like
The pieces a advertising agencies business puts in place, in an order that makes each easier. Open any card for the detail.
Write what each seat owns
A one-page description for copywriter, art director, planner, servicing lead and producer, showing who owns the brief, the deadline and the final sign-off.
What this coversHide
Write what each seat owns
A one-page description for copywriter, art director, planner, servicing lead and producer, showing who owns the brief, the deadline and the final sign-off.
What this coversHideA one-page description for copywriter, art director, planner, servicing lead and producer, showing who owns the brief, the deadline and the final sign-off. See role design and job descriptions.
Rotate pitch teams and track the load
A record of who worked on which pitch and how many weekends it took, so the same few are not drained and the work is recognised in reviews.
What this coversHide
Rotate pitch teams and track the load
A record of who worked on which pitch and how many weekends it took, so the same few are not drained and the work is recognised in reviews.
What this coversHideA record of who worked on which pitch and how many weekends it took, so the same few are not drained and the work is recognised in reviews.
Set a clear step ladder for creatives
Defined steps from junior to creative director with the skills expected at each, so a promotion rests on what people can do.
What this coversHide
Set a clear step ladder for creatives
Defined steps from junior to creative director with the skills expected at each, so a promotion rests on what people can do.
What this coversHideDefined steps from junior to creative director with the skills expected at each, so a promotion rests on what people can do. The compensation benchmarking work checks the pay at each step.
Plan staffing against the campaign calendar
A forward view of launches and festival peaks, with named people and freelancer cover, built with workforce planning.
What this coversHide
Plan staffing against the campaign calendar
A forward view of launches and festival peaks, with named people and freelancer cover, built with workforce planning.
What this coversHideA forward view of launches and festival peaks, with named people and freelancer cover, built with workforce planning.
Give interns a structure
A named mentor, a first-month plan and a review at the end of the term that says whether a job is on offer.
What this coversHide
Give interns a structure
A named mentor, a first-month plan and a review at the end of the term that says whether a job is on offer.
What this coversHideA named mentor, a first-month plan and a review at the end of the term that says whether a job is on offer.
Hold feedback sessions on a fixed schedule
Short reviews tied to the work delivered, with examples, rather than annual conversations about attitude.
What this coversHide
Hold feedback sessions on a fixed schedule
Short reviews tied to the work delivered, with examples, rather than annual conversations about attitude.
What this coversHideShort reviews tied to the work delivered, with examples, rather than annual conversations about attitude. The performance management and incentive design work builds this.
Start by checking where you stand
Before changing anything, find out what is true today. These checks take an afternoon and tell you which of the topics above to start with.
Share your requirements- Count the pitches in the last year, who worked on them and how many were won.
- Write one page on what a servicing lead and a creative director each own.
- Check how long your senior copywriters and art directors have held their current titles.
- Map the work your agency expects over the next six months against who is free.
- Ask your interns of the last two years what they were told about jobs.
- Confirm with a qualified professional the employment, intern and intellectual property rules that apply to an advertising agency like yours.
Confirm with a qualified professional. What applies to you depends on your business, your state and your arrangements, and it changes. This page describes practice. It does not state a legal position.
How GullyHR helps
The services below fit this kind of business best. Each starts by recording where you stand, and every later report compares against that. We do not promise outcomes.
- Role design and job descriptions
Clear seats for servicing, creative and planning, so briefs and sign-offs stop sliding between people.
- Performance management and incentive design
Review and reward design that values pitches won and campaigns delivered, not just visible hours.
- Compensation benchmarking
A pay view for creatives and servicing leads, so a rival offer does not catch you off guard.
- Leadership and people management
Training for creative directors who became people managers because they were good at ideas.
Start with a free conversation, or see the paid HR Diagnostic.
Our HR transformation approach
- 1
Assess
Understand the business, its workforce, current processes and HR challenges.
- 2
Identify gaps
Find the missing, weak, inconsistent or person-dependent processes.
- 3
Design
Create the structure, processes, policies, SOPs, dashboards and systems needed.
- 4
Implement
Help HR and department managers actually adopt the new system.
- 5
Automate
Digitise repetitive and approval-based workflows where it is worth doing.
- 6
Measure
Track hiring, attendance, employee cost, performance, training and attrition.
- 7
Improve
Strengthen the people-management system continuously, not once.
Blogs worth reading first
From the GullyHR blog: one on HR in marketing, advertising and creative, and one on each of the topics this page points to.
HR Management
Everyone reports to the founder: when and how to redesign the structure
A flat structure works until the founder becomes the only route to a decision. How to tell when you have passed that point, and how to redesign without a reorganisation.
8 min readRead article
Industries
Measuring performance in chemical and specialty chemical makers: what to track and what to ignore
Measures that show how reactor, console, lab and gantry staff are really doing, the ones that mislead or bury near misses, and a monthly sheet an in-charge can run in twenty minutes.
7 min readRead article
Industries
Incentives that reward quality, not just output, in industrial component makers
How to design incentives for operators, setters and inspectors in fastener, gear, spring and valve units so that accepted lots, not piece counts, earn the bonus.
7 min readRead articleMore on the GullyHR blog.
Questions owners ask
Record who worked on each pitch and for how long, and treat it as real work in the review. Pitch effort that is never seen by management leads to burnout and quiet resignations from the people you most need.
Usually because ownership of the brief and the deadline is unclear. Put in writing who writes the brief, who can change it and what happens after a change. The argument then becomes a process question.
A written ladder with the skills and work samples expected at each step, reviewed twice a year. People accept slower movement when they can see what is next and what stands between them and it.
Decide the purpose of the programme first. If interns do real client work, treat them as part of the team with a mentor and a clear end-of-term decision. Confirm the rules on stipends with a qualified professional.
Talk about growth before they do, benchmark pay against the market and give them a visible next step. Ask what they want to work on. Most leave over no path, not just money.
We would ask how pitch work is shared and recorded, who owns the brief at each stage and how long your senior creatives have held their titles. A good first project is a role clarity page for servicing and creative plus a step ladder for creatives. Scope is then written down for you to accept or change.
More on HR for marketing, advertising and creative
All 8 business types in marketing, advertising & creative agencies · Find another business type
Digital marketing agenciesDesign agenciesPR agenciesBranding studiosSEO agenciesSocial media agenciesOrganisation Design in marketing, advertising and creativePerformance Management in marketing, advertising and creativeCompensation, Payroll and Benefits in marketing, advertising and creative
See all HR topics for marketing, advertising and creative, or another industry.