Set Pay by Structure, Not by Negotiation
We compare what you pay for each role with market data for the same role in the same city. You get pay bands, grades and a written increment policy. Every figure shows its source and the number of data points behind it.

Make this work for your business. Share your team size, priorities and what you need help with. We’ll use your brief to prepare for the first conversation.
Share your requirementsCompensation Benchmarking and Salary Structures in brief
Compensation benchmarking compares what you pay for each role with what the market pays for the same role in the same city. GullyHR turns the result into pay bands and grades, a written increment policy and a list of roles paid outside the band, so offers and revisions follow a structure instead of whoever negotiated hardest. Every figure states its source and how many data points sit behind it.
by the GullyHR consulting team
- A defined project that starts from your own pay data and roles mapped to a common framework, and ends in grades, pay bands, a placement of every employee and an increment policy.
- Every benchmarked figure states its source and the number of data points behind it; where data is too thin, the range is marked indicative or left out rather than guessed.
- Pay decisions stay with you. GullyHR shows what each market position costs and which roles it moves; you decide what to pay and where to sit.
- It is the data-led half of the rewards work: the compensation and rewards strategy page covers pay philosophy, variable pay and recognition, and benchmarking can sit inside it.
- Statutory pay components are identified but not opined on; confirm them with a qualified professional, because the rules depend on your establishment and state.
The starting point
Do You Know Where You Stand Against the Market?
Pay drifts quietly. Each new hire is priced at whatever the market asked that month, nobody already inside is brought up to it, and the gap only becomes visible when a good employee leaves for a number you could have matched.
We benchmark role by role in the city you hire in, build bands around the result and cost the gaps.
You may be experiencing:
- Every offer being a negotiation, so the hardest bargainer earns more than the better performer.
- A good employee leaving for a competitor's offer, and finding afterwards that the role had moved well past what you paid.
- Freshers earning close to long-serving colleagues, because new hires were priced at market and nobody else was.
- A large increase given to retain one person, which the rest of the team knew about within a month.
- No way to say what a new hire in a role may be offered without asking the founder.
- Increments decided by whoever is in the room, with no rule for what a strong year should earn.
- A second city being added, with no idea whether the same role should be paid the same there.
What we can help with
What the Benchmarking Covers
City-Wise Benchmarking
A salary for the same role differs between one city and another, so each role is benchmarked where you actually hire for it rather than against a national average that applies nowhere.
Source Transparency
Each figure carries where it came from and how many data points sit behind it, so you can see which benchmarks are solid and which are indicative, rather than being handed one confident number.
Grade Grouping
Roles grouped into grades by the size of the job rather than by title, so that a generous designation handed out years ago does not quietly set the pay for a whole level.
Pay Band Construction
A minimum, midpoint and maximum for each grade, built from the benchmark and from where you decide to sit against it, grade by grade rather than as a single company-wide position.
Employee Placement
Every current employee placed in their grade, with those below the minimum, above the maximum and bunched at one end listed explicitly, because the outliers are what the exercise is for.
Gap Costing and Phasing
What closing each gap would cost, with a suggested phasing you can accept or change, so the correction becomes a number you decided to accept rather than a surprise.
Increment and Offer Rules
What an increment is based on, when it is decided, how a promotion differs from a revision, what happens to someone at the top of a band, and the approval limits within which a manager may make an offer.
Benefits Review
Fixed and variable pay, allowances, insurance, leave and the statutory components looked at together, so you can see what a role actually costs rather than only what the salary line says.
The scope
What the Consulting Covers
The aim is to replace case-by-case pay decisions with a structure you can explain and afford. These are the parts we can review or design. The scope is agreed with you and can take all areas or only some.
Current Pay Review
Existing salaries by role, grade and location, recent offers and the pay reasons given in exits.
Role Inventory and Job Matching
The list of roles to benchmark and how each is matched to a comparable market role, with the limits of the match stated.
Market Data Collection
Published surveys, recruitment consultant quotes and your own offer and exit data, each source recorded.
Location Differentials
How the same role is priced in each city or plant you hire in, and which market sets the price for remote roles.
Grade Structure
How many grades the business needs now and which roles sit in each, based on the size of the job.
Pay Bands and Ranges
A minimum, midpoint and maximum for each grade, and the position you choose against the market.
Fixed and Variable Pay Mix
How fixed pay, allowances and variable pay are balanced for each grade and role family.
Employee Placement and Outliers
Where each person sits in their band, including those below the minimum, above the maximum or bunched together.
Gap Costing and Phasing
The cost of closing each gap and a suggested sequence for you to accept or change.
Increment and Promotion Rules
What an increment is based on, how a promotion is priced and what happens at the top of a band.
Offer Approval and Exceptions
The band within which a manager may make an offer, who approves beyond it and how exceptions are recorded.
Benefits and Total Cost View
Pay, allowances, insurance and leave read together so you can see what a role costs.
Working together
Ways to Work With Us
Pay Position Check
A short look at where you stand: a handful of key roles benchmarked, a first view of who sits outside a sensible range and a recommended next step.
Salary Structure Project
The defined project: benchmarks, grades, bands, employee placement, increment policy and benefits review, delivered as documents and a walk-through.
Structure With Performance
The pay structure built alongside goal setting and incentive design, so what you reward matches what you measure.
Yearly Refresh
A smaller piece of work each year to update the benchmarks, re-place employees and adjust the bands before the increment cycle opens.
We do not hold a proprietary salary survey. Benchmarks are assembled from published surveys, recruitment consultant quotes and your own offer and exit data, with the reliability of each marked.
The deliverables
What You Receive
Depending on the scope of your engagement, deliverables can include:
- A benchmark for each role, by city, with the source and the number of data points shown beside each figure.
- A grade structure that groups your roles by the size of the job.
- A pay band for each grade: minimum, midpoint and maximum.
- A placement of every employee against the band, with those below the minimum and above the maximum listed.
- A costed plan for closing the gaps, with a suggested phasing for you to accept or change.
- A written increment and promotion policy.
- Offer approval limits and a route for exceptions.
- A benefits and statutory components review, for confirmation with a qualified professional.
- A role-matching record showing which market role each of your roles was compared with, and how closely it matched.
- A note on grades where newer joiners and longer-serving employees sit close together on pay.
- A short guide for managers on explaining bands, increments and exceptions to employees.
Step by step
How We Work
Record the Starting Point
We take your current salary data, the offers made over the last year and the pay-related reasons given in exits. This becomes the baseline every later report compares against.
Define Roles and Grades
We agree the list of roles to benchmark, group them by the size of the job and settle how many grades the business actually needs now, which can be fewer than people expect.
Benchmark Each Role in Its City
For each role we gather market data for the city where you hire, state where each figure comes from and how many data points sit behind it, and mark which benchmarks are indicative rather than solid.
Choose Where You Want to Sit
We show what it costs to pay at, above or below the market midpoint for each grade. You decide the position grade by grade, and the reason behind each choice is written down.
Build Bands, Place People and Hand Over
Ranges are built, every employee placed, and the outliers listed with the cost of closing each gap. The increment policy and offer limits are written, and a yearly review date is fixed. Where it is included in the engagement, a pilot with one function or one location is run first, and the bands and policy are refined from what managers and HR found before wider use.
The difference
What a Structure Gives You
A benchmarked pay structure helps you:
We do not promise outcomes. We record a baseline before work starts, covering current salaries by role and city, recent offers and the pay reasons given in exits, and report against it, so you can see what changed and what did not.
- Make offers inside a band the hiring manager can read, without a call to the founder.
- Explain why two people in the same role earn what they earn.
- Understand pay-related exits, because you know which roles sit below market and which do not.
- Run increments on a written rule, so the conversation is about the employee's year rather than the budget.
- Treat the cost of closing pay gaps as a number you decided to accept rather than a surprise.
- Price a role in a new city against local data rather than against what head office pays.
- Match each role to a comparable market role, with the match and its limits written down.
- See where newer joiners and longer-serving employees sit close together on pay.
- Prepare a revision cycle with a costed range rather than a figure agreed under pressure.
- Explain a pay decision to an employee, an auditor or an investor by pointing to the band and the policy.
Find your fit
Who This Service Is For
Founder-Led Businesses
Companies where every salary was agreed one at a time and nobody can describe the logic behind the result.
Companies Losing People on Pay
Businesses that have lost employees to better offers and want to know where they actually stand.
Businesses Opening a Second City
Companies adding a location or plant, where the same role will be paid differently and nobody is sure by how much.
Teams About to Hire a Layer
Businesses recruiting a senior layer or a batch of fresh graduates and unsure what to offer.
Companies Facing Diligence
Businesses preparing for a funding round, a diligence review or an audit, where pay needs to be explained.
Businesses That Just Introduced Grades
Companies that have set up levels and now need a pay structure that matches them.
HR Heads Preparing an Increment Cycle
Teams that want a written basis and a costed range before the cycle opens, instead of a budget agreed late.
Finance Teams Planning Hiring Cost
Teams that need pay ranges by role and city to plan headcount budgets.
Businesses Hiring Remotely or in Several Cities
Companies pricing the same role across markets who need a stated rule for which market sets the pay.
Good to know
Benchmark Only, or the Full Rewards Strategy?
Choose benchmarking when
- You want to know how your pay compares with the market for each role and city, and get grades and bands you can run from.
- An increment cycle, a funding round or a run of lost offers has made the question urgent.
- You already have a pay philosophy, or are content to decide market position grade by grade as the figures come in.
Choose compensation and rewards strategy when
- You need to decide what pay should reward before you decide how much of it to pay.
- Variable pay, benefits, recognition or long-term incentives are part of the question.
- You want one framework across all of these, with benchmarking as one step inside it.
Good to know
From Benchmark to Yearly Refresh
Building the structure
- Baseline: record current pay, recent offers and pay-related exits.
- Match: agree the roles and match each to a comparable market role.
- Benchmark: gather data for each city, marking each source and how reliable it is.
Using and refreshing it
- Decide: choose the position against the market for each grade.
- Place: set bands, place employees and cost the gaps.
- Refresh: update the benchmarks and bands before each increment cycle.
Pay data ages quickly. The refresh step keeps the bands and policy in step with the markets you hire in.
Good to know
Cost of closing the gap: at once or in stages
Two options, one formula each
- Gap for one person: band minimum minus current pay.
- Cost of closing at once: the sum of all gaps.
- Cost of staging: the same gaps spread over N increment cycles.
- The owner chooses, because the costed options are shown side by side.
Why it matters
Letters stand in for figures. Your actual numbers come from your salary register and the band chosen.
Good to know
City differences, without one national number
How cities are handled
- The same role is benchmarked for each city where you hire.
- A second location is benchmarked separately, not adjusted by a rule of thumb.
- Where data for a smaller town is thin, the range is marked indicative and fewer sources are named.
Good to know
Track Pay Position
Structure and placement
- Position in band: where employees sit between the minimum and the maximum.
- Employees outside the band: who is below the minimum or above the maximum.
- Pay closeness between new and longer-serving employees: where the difference is narrow.
- Benchmark age: when each role's market data was last refreshed.
Offers, exits and revisions
- Offer position: where recent offers land against the band midpoint.
- Pay-related exits: the share of leavers giving pay as a reason for leaving, by role and grade.
- Increment spread: how revisions are distributed across grades and ratings.
- Gap-closure progress: what was agreed and what has been delivered.
Measures use agreed definitions, and salary figures are reported at the level of detail agreed with you.
Good to know
Scope and Service Boundaries
Each engagement defines
The roles, cities and employee categories covered, whether variable pay and benefits are included, the data sources used, the deliverables and the implementation support provided.
Requires a separate agreement
- Payroll processing or salary disbursement.
- Opinions on statutory pay and benefit components.
- Job evaluation across the whole organisation.
- Incentive and variable pay scheme design beyond what is agreed in scope.
- Negotiating individual offers or counter-offers on your behalf.
- Yearly refreshes beyond the agreed period.
Pay decisions and your position against the market remain with authorised management. Policies and any statutory components should receive appropriate specialist review.
Good to know
Timeline and How to Prepare
Timeline
The schedule depends on the number of roles and cities, how clean the salary records are and how quickly decisions on positioning can be taken. We confirm it after agreeing the scope.
Useful inputs
- Current salary records by role, grade and location.
- Offer data for roles filled over the last year.
- Exit records with any pay-related reasons.
- Any existing grade or level structure.
- The current increment policy and the last cycle's decisions.
- Details of allowances, variable pay and benefits.
Where possible we work with coded or redacted records, and we agree the form in which salary data is shared.
Good to know
Confidentiality and Salary Information
Handled by agreement
Salary records are among the most sensitive information a business holds. Before work begins we agree what data is needed, who may access it, how it is stored and shared, the confidentiality terms and retention arrangements.
Market contacts
Whether and how any of your figures are shared when we approach recruitment consultants for market quotes is agreed with you first, including whether they are anonymised.
What it looks like
A Sample Grade and Band Extract
An illustrative extract of the kind of structure the project produces. Letters stand in for the figures, which come from your data and the benchmark.
| Example roles | Band for the city | Employees outside the band | Suggested treatment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| G1 Entry | Office assistant, trainee, junior executive | Minimum A, midpoint B, maximum C | None | Hold; review at next refresh |
| G2 Executive | Accounts executive, recruiter, support executive | Set from the city benchmark with the spread you choose | One below minimum (recent internal move) | Correct at the next increment cycle |
| G3 Senior executive | Senior accountant, senior developer, senior sales executive | Set from the city benchmark with the spread you choose | Two above maximum (long tenure) | Freeze fixed pay; move growth to variable |
| G4 Team lead | Team lead, assistant manager | Set from the city benchmark with the spread you choose | One below minimum (hired in a slow market) | Phase the correction over two cycles |
| G5 Manager | Function manager, branch head | Set from the city benchmark with the spread you choose | None | Hold |
Illustrative only. The real grades, the roles in each, the spread of each band and the list of people outside it depend on your role inventory, the cities you hire in and your pay data.
Which one fits
Benchmarking or compensation strategy
Benchmarking tells you where you stand, while strategy decides what to do about it.
| Compensation benchmarking | Compensation strategy | Increment and promotion policy | |
|---|---|---|---|
| When it fits | You need to see how roles and employees sit against the market | You need a full design with grades, incentives and approval rules | You already know your bands and need rules for pay change |
| What you get | Role benchmarks with sources, bands, placement and a costed gap plan | Philosophy, job evaluation, grades, incentive plans and recognition rules | A written policy for increments, promotions and exceptions |
| Who does the work | We gather and compare data, and you choose the position | We run evaluation and drafting, and you approve every number | We draft the policy, and your managers apply it |
| What it does not cover | Incentive plan design or a live market database | External pay surveys bought on your behalf | Benchmarking or building the band structure |
| What happens next | You decide which gaps to close now and which to phase | Rules are adopted and managers are briefed | Policy runs on the cycle calendar |
Benchmarks are a snapshot with a stated date, so they are refreshed when you next review pay.
How we both know it is done
When the benchmarking work counts as finished
The work is accepted when
- Every benchmark line shows its source, the date of the data and the sample size beside the figure.
- Thin or conflicting evidence is flagged in writing, with the reason a figure was or was not used.
- Each grade has a band with minimum, midpoint and maximum, and every employee is placed against it.
- Employees below the minimum and above the maximum are listed with costed options for each gap.
- Offer approval limits and an exception route are written down and confirmed by your leadership.
What you provide
- A salary register with roles, locations and current pay components.
- The cities and the role families you want compared, listed with priorities.
- Your decision on where in the market you want to sit.
- A view on which gaps to close now and which to phase.
Before you enquire
Benchmarking Is Not the Right Fit If
We would rather say so here than after a call. If one of these describes you, the links alongside point to what will serve you better.
- You want a pay philosophy, variable pay design or a recognition scheme rather than a market comparison; that is the compensation and rewards strategy page.
- You need a sales incentive or bonus scheme designed; see performance and incentive design.
- You want to be told the one right salary for a role; we show a range with its sources and limits and you choose the position.
- You are looking to buy a published salary survey; GullyHR does not sell survey data.
Compensation and rewards strategy →Performance and incentive design →
How we are measured
Before work starts, we record where you stand. Every later report compares against that baseline.
We choose the measures with you at the start, from the list on this page, and only the ones your data can support. We do not promise a result. We promise a baseline, and a report that shows the change against it, whichever way it went.
This engagement is measured on
- Share of roles paid within their band
- Offer acceptance rate
- Pay-related exits, as recorded in exit interviews
The measures we choose from
Time-to-hire
Days from approved vacancy to accepted offer.
90-day attrition
New joiners who leave in their first three months.
Annual attrition
Leavers over the year, by team and by manager.
Payroll and statutory errors per month
Corrections after the run, and returns filed late.
Open compliance gaps
Obligations without an owner or a due date.
Employees with written goals
Share of the team that knows what it is measured on.
Review completion rate
Reviews finished on time, not just started.
Manager training coverage
Managers who have been taught the part of the job they were promoted into.
Good to know
Frequently asked questions
It compares what you pay for each role with what the market pays for the same role in the same city, and turns the result into grades, pay bands, a written increment policy and a list of roles paid outside the band.
We start with your own pay data: current salaries, recent offers, counter-offers and the pay reasons given in exits. Each role is mapped to a common framework so like is compared with like. Where publicly available ranges exist for a role and city we use them and state how many data points sit behind each figure. The sources used for your roles are named in the proposal, and where the data is too thin to benchmark honestly we say so instead of producing a number.
We show what it costs to sit at, above or below the market midpoint for each grade, and recommend where that choice matters. The position you take is yours, and it may differ by grade depending on how hard each is to hire.
Yes, and it matters more than people expect. The same role commands different pay in a metro and in a smaller town, so benchmarking against a national average produces a band that is too high in one place and too low in another.
This is the market-facing, data-led piece: what roles are worth outside and how your pay compares. Rewards strategy is broader, covering the pay philosophy, job evaluation, variable pay design, promotion treatment and recognition. Benchmarking sits inside it as one step.
Where data is thin we mark the benchmark as indicative, and where there is too little to benchmark honestly we say so rather than produce a number. A reasoned range with its limits stated is more useful than a confident figure.
Each case is listed with the cost of closing the gap and a suggested sequence, as in the sample extract above. You decide which to correct, how quickly and which to hold, and the reason is recorded against the person.
The benefits review looks at fixed and variable pay, allowances, insurance and leave together so you can see total cost. Statutory components are identified but not opined on. Please confirm those with a qualified professional.
Current salary records, recent offers and counter-offers, exit reasons, any existing grades and your increment policy. We can work with coded or redacted records, and we agree the form of data sharing before anything is exchanged.
A pay position check on a handful of roles is short. A full structure project depends on how many roles and cities are in scope and how clean the salary data is. The timeline is stated in the proposal after the role list is agreed.
A handful of key roles, chosen at scoping. The usual picks are the hardest to hire, the largest in headcount and the ones with recent exits. A full structure project covers the rest.
Some businesses refresh once a year before the increment cycle, and sooner when they open a new city or hire a new layer. We agree a cadence with you based on how quickly your roles move.
The number of roles and cities, how clean and complete your salary data is, whether you want a position check or a full grade structure with placement and increment rules, and whether we brief managers and stay for the first increment cycle. How long it takes depends on the number of roles and cities and how clean your salary data is. The time you give is mostly a role list, a salary register and a decision on the pay position you want. We state the schedule and a written quote after a short scoping call.
Not necessarily. CIPD's reward factsheet reports that private-sector service employers in the UK aim for the midpoint of the range for a satisfactory performer, while manufacturing and voluntary employers are more divided. Which position suits you depends on how hard each role is to fill, what the business can afford and how quickly people grow in the role. The aim is to choose a position on purpose and write it down. You make that call; the benchmarking shows what each option would cost.
That is your decision. A CIPD survey of 832 UK HR and reward professionals (October 2023) found that employers were far more likely to publish ranges than specific salaries, and the report recommends sharing pay-scale information with existing employees. If you do share, share the band and where the person sits in it, not other people's pay.
Research and practice
What research and practice say
Benchmarks fail at the matching step more than at the data step. A title such as Executive or Manager can cover very different work in different businesses, so a survey figure for the title can mislead. Match on what the job does, the decisions it carries and the people it leads, and only then read the number. When a market figure looks wrong, check the match before you doubt the market.
CIPD sets market pricing, which follows external labour-market rates, against job evaluation, which ranks jobs by how they relate to one another inside the business, and notes that employers vary pay by location because of living costs and local labour-market tightness. For you, that means a benchmark needs the market view, the internal ranking and a separate figure for each city.
CIPD reports that private-sector service employers in the UK aim to pay a satisfactory performer around the midpoint of the pay range, while voluntary, manufacturing and production employers are more divided. Choose your target position deliberately for each role family instead of inheriting it from whoever set the first salary.
The ILO's India Wage Report examines wage gaps by sector and occupation, the split between organised and unorganised work, and regular versus casual work by location and gender. A single national average blends very different labour markets, so compare like with like: same occupation, same kind of employer, same city.
Source: ILO, India Wage Report: Wage policies for decent work and inclusive growth (2018)
A CIPD survey of 832 UK HR and reward professionals (October 2023) found employers far more likely to publish salary ranges than specific salaries, and the report recommends showing where a successful candidate would start on a pay scale. A band built from benchmarks is most useful when each offer says where in the band the person begins.
Source: CIPD, Pay, performance and transparency report (2024)
The ILO's job evaluation guidance stresses assessing different jobs against common, objective criteria so that work of equal value is paid equally. Match each role to market data on what the job does, the decisions it carries and the people it leads, not on its title.
Source: ILO, Promoting Equity: Gender-neutral job evaluation for equal pay, a step-by-step guide (2009)
We summarise these sources in our own words. Open the link for the full findings and the method behind them.
Read on
Guides, tools and templates
- Compensation and rewards strategy
The hub for pay philosophy, variable pay, benefits and recognition.
- Increment and promotion policy
The rules that use the bands each cycle.
- CTC break-up calculator
See how a figure splits into components.
- Role design and job descriptions
Roles need defining before they can be matched.
Find Out Where You Stand, Then Set the Bands
Benchmark each role in the city you hire in, group roles into grades, build bands around them, and see exactly who sits outside and what closing the gap would cost.
Prefer to talk first? Call +91 80958 58589 or write to hello@gullyhr.com.
Book a Benchmarking Consultation
Tell us which roles and cities you need benchmarked.


