Why agency employees leave and how to understand why
Creatives, planners and account teams leave for reasons beyond pay. How to run an exit conversation in an agency, spot patterns by account and act on them.
7 min readRead articleAn SEO agency sells slow, measured results to clients who want them fast. Its people are analysts, writers and link builders whose work shows up months later, so judging effort fairly and keeping good specialists is the hard part.

Not sure what you need? Tell us about your business in six short steps and we will come to the first meeting prepared.
Share your requirementsAn SEO agency runs retainers for clients who want more visitors from search. The team has technical SEO analysts, content writers, outreach and link specialists, a reporting analyst and account managers. Work moves in monthly cycles: audits, fixes, content, outreach and a report on the client's rankings and traffic. Results lag the effort by months and can swing after a search engine update that nobody in the agency controls. A strong analyst knows when to say no to a client. Bench strength matters because a few people hold the knowledge of each account. The wider marketing and creative agencies page covers what agencies share.
These are the places the people side of this kind of business tends to give way. The rest of this page works through them.
HR here has to work for each of these groups, not only the office. The set-up below is written with all of them in mind.
GullyHR runs talent acquisition for permanent roles in SEO agencies. For each role we agree the job description with you, find and screen candidates against it, and support the offer through to joining. Tell us the role and the number of people, and we start there.
We recruit permanent employees. We do not supply contract or temporary staff.
Every business interviews, but few have a written process that works the same way for every role and every interviewer. GullyHR designs yours, from the role brief to the offer, trains your managers to run it, and can run it for you on the roles you hand us.
We agree what the role must deliver, the must-have and nice-to-have skills, and how each will be scored.
Screening call, assessment, interview rounds and decision points, sized to the role and the number of people you hire.
Structured questions for each role family and a rating guide, so two interviewers judge the same answer the same way.
A short briefing for your managers on what to ask, what to avoid and how to give a clear yes or no.
Who approves, how the offer is made, and how candidates are kept informed from first call to joining.
A good month of work can show nothing until the next quarter, so reviews reward whoever happened to hold a rising account.
Rankings move for reasons outside anyone's control, and the team is asked to explain it to clients by evening.
Analysts spend days pulling the same numbers into client decks, and the thinking work waits.
When that person leaves, the history of what was tried and why leaves with them.
Pieces are counted but depth is not, and good writers get tired of pushing out thin articles.
The team is judged on keyword positions, while the owner knows sales and enquiries matter more.
Tools, search features and practices change every season, and learning happens on personal time if at all.
Start with the topics that matter most here: Performance Management; Learning and Development; Retention and Attrition Management. Then work through the rest. Each topic is written for marketing, advertising and creative, not in general.
Goals, reviews and ratings that hold up in a conversation.
Training planned from need rather than from the calendar.
Who leaves, when, why, and which of them mattered.
How many people, in which roles, by when, and what they will cost.
Structure, reporting lines and who is allowed to decide what.
Requisition to joining, the same way every time.
A first day that is the same for the fifth joiner as the first.
Records, attendance, leave and the day-to-day HR that must simply work.
Salary structure, payroll inputs and a month that closes on time.
Named backups for the roles that cannot be vacant.
Communication, recognition and the conditions people actually work in.
Two routes, one for complaints, one for conduct, kept separate.
Policies a manager can apply, and obligations with owners and dates.
Induction, records, incident reporting and follow-through.
Resignation to relieving letter, in a defined order.
Records that survive people, and approvals that do not queue.
A short monthly pack management actually reads.
An HR function that runs the same way every month.
The pieces a SEO agencies business puts in place, in an order that makes each easier. Open any card for the detail.
One page for analysts, writers, outreach and reporting staff, so work is not shifted by whoever shouts loudest.
One page for analysts, writers, outreach and reporting staff, so work is not shifted by whoever shouts loudest. Role design is the place to start.
Judge people on the quality of audits, fixes shipped and content delivered, plus client results over a longer window.
Judge people on the quality of audits, fixes shipped and content delivered, plus client results over a longer window. Avoid single month rank charts. Performance management can set this.
A short running note per client on what was tried, what worked and why, so a handover takes days and not weeks.
A short running note per client on what was tried, what worked and why, so a handover takes days and not weeks.
A fixed weekly slot for testing, reading and sharing, tied to the skills each role needs next.
A fixed weekly slot for testing, reading and sharing, tied to the skills each role needs next. The learning and development process holds the plan.
A common template with the narrative written by the analyst, so assembling takes hours and not days.
A common template with the narrative written by the analyst, so assembling takes hours and not days.
A short note on who speaks to clients, what is said and what the team does when rankings move.
A short note on who speaks to clients, what is said and what the team does when rankings move.
Before changing anything, find out what is true today. Work through the checks using a recent operating period. The time needed depends on the records you hold; note missing evidence and use the findings to choose a priority.
Share your requirementsConfirm with a qualified professional. What applies to you depends on your business, your state and your arrangements, and it changes. This page describes practice. It does not state a legal position.
The services below fit this kind of business best. Each starts by recording where you stand, and every later report compares against that. We do not promise outcomes.
Clear remits for analysts, writers and outreach staff so overlaps and gaps are visible.
A review cycle that weighs inputs and delayed client results fairly.
A weekly learning slot and skills plan that keeps specialists current.
A view of why analysts leave and what would keep the strong ones.
Start with a free conversation, or see the paid HR Diagnostic.
Understand the business, its workforce, current processes and HR challenges.
Find the missing, weak, inconsistent or person-dependent processes.
Create the structure, processes, policies, SOPs, dashboards and systems needed.
Help HR and department managers actually adopt the new system.
Digitise repetitive and approval-based workflows where it is worth doing.
Track hiring, attendance, employee cost, performance, training and attrition.
Strengthen the people-management system continuously, not once.
From the GullyHR blog: one on HR in marketing, advertising and creative, and one on each of the topics this page points to.

Creatives, planners and account teams leave for reasons beyond pay. How to run an exit conversation in an agency, spot patterns by account and act on them.
7 min readRead article
A practical design for an IT services appraisal cycle: when to run it, how to rate fairly across projects, and how to explain hikes so they hold.
7 min readRead article
A founder's guide to hiring freshers and running a first-year programme: campus or open drives, a screening round, a training plan by quarter, mentors and checkpoints.
6 min readRead article
What really keeps mobile app and web developers in a small firm: stay conversations, growth paths, fair release rules and a risk sheet an owner can use this month.
6 min readRead articleMore on the GullyHR blog.
Look at the work they controlled, such as audit quality, fixes shipped and content delivered, then add client results over a longer window. Avoid grading on one month of rankings that an update could have shifted.
Give them room to write fewer, better pieces, a clear route to editor or strategist, and pay that reflects quality. Some leave because volume targets leave no room for craft.
Agree a simple plan in advance: who reviews the changes, who speaks to each client and by when. A calm, shared script protects both the clients and the team's evenings.
Yes. A common template, a clear owner for the narrative and agreed dates remove most of the hand assembly. The analyst's time should go into what the numbers mean.
Keep a short history note for every account, pair a second person with each major client and review notes monthly. Handover then becomes a conversation, not a rescue.
First we would ask what your analysts do in the last week of the month, list accounts that depend on one person and see how past reviews treated update weeks. A role page for each function plus a fair review frame is a natural first job, with scope agreed in writing.
All 8 business types in marketing, advertising & creative agencies · Find another business type
See all HR topics for marketing, advertising and creative, or another industry.
Tell us your industry, team size and the issue you want to address. Bring one example of where work gets delayed or ownership is unclear, and the deadline or decision you are working towards.