Why professional services employees leave and how to understand why
Why associates and managers leave consulting, accounting, legal and advisory firms, and how to ask about progression, workload and partners at exit.
6 min readRead articleA management consulting firm sells consultant time to client engagements. Partners win the work, managers run it and analysts do the digging, and profit depends on how well people are deployed and kept.

Make this work for your business. Share your team size, priorities and what you need help with. We’ll use your brief to prepare for the first conversation.
Share your requirementsA management consulting firm has a few partners or principals, a layer of project managers and a larger group of consultants and analysts. Work comes as engagements of a few weeks to several months at client premises or remotely. Each engagement needs a team of a certain mix, and the people between engagements sit on the bench. Timesheets feed invoices and utilisation. Travel is frequent and expenses are claimed on return. Growth depends on whether juniors get exposure fast enough to become managers. See also the management and business consulting hub and the professional services sector page.
These are the places the people side of this kind of business tends to give way. The rest of this page works through them.
Why GullyHR for management consulting
For partners and managers of consulting firms who staff engagements by instinct. GullyHR sets up allocation, timesheet, grade and travel routines, so deployment is visible and juniors see how they progress.
We write the agenda and the one-page bench list that partners and managers review together, so upcoming engagements and idle consultants are matched on need and development, not on who the partner knows.
A competency grid for analyst, consultant, senior consultant and manager, with sample engagement tasks at each level, so promotion rounds stop ending in surprise and quiet exits.
A short daily entry against each engagement code and a weekly manager check replace Friday guesses, so invoices and utilisation figures rest on what people actually did.
Class of travel, allowances and claim timing are written once and applied alike to partners and analysts, so client-site weeks stop producing late and uneven claims.
Start with any one of these. Scope and fee are agreed in writing after a free first conversation.
We start with the allocation history for the past year and mark every gap between engagements, by consultant and by grade. Timesheets are set beside what engagement managers say people actually did, and travel claims are read for late or unusual patterns. Then we talk to analysts, senior consultants, managers, the finance and timesheet staff and the travel desk, asking what separates one grade from the next and who decides staffing. Exits in the early years are traced to where people went and why. The findings come back grade by grade, in plain language, to the partners.
What you receive
An example, not a client storySuppose a partner notices that two consultants have waited for weeks while a third moves straight from one engagement to the next. The review would trace how staffing was decided, compare timesheets with what managers recall, and show the partners where allocation rests on personal preference instead of on need and development.
How the hr audit works →Allocation comes first, because the bench is where margin leaks. We sit with partners and engagement managers, map how a team is picked today, and write a fortnightly allocation meeting with its inputs and decisions. Next comes the timesheet routine, then the end-of-engagement feedback talk, then the travel and expense note covering class of travel, allowances, claim timing and client-paid costs. Each document names who acts, in what order, and what is recorded, so analysts and partners follow the same steps. We test them against live engagements before they are fixed.
What you receive
An example, not a client storyPicture a firm where each manager writes feedback from memory, weeks after the team has moved on. A short written talk is set up at the close of each engagement, with a form both sides sign. When promotion time comes, the partners read dated notes instead of recollections of a project long finished.
How the hr process design works →Week to week, we prepare the bench list before each allocation meeting and record what was decided. We chase late timesheets with managers and flag entries that look guessed. Appraisal and promotion rounds are scheduled, with feedback notes gathered from each engagement. We follow travel claims through to completion and watch for unusual patterns, and we keep the records of joiners, leavers and moves between engagements current. A short weekly note goes to the partners covering bench time, open claims, upcoming rounds and any consultant who looks ready to leave.
What you receive
An example, not a client storySay the partners notice that allocation is slipping back into habit after two busy proposal weeks. With the service running, the bench list is prepared before each meeting, a consultant waiting too long is flagged, and the managers who owe feedback notes are reminded before the next promotion round, so nobody is judged on a thin file.
How the hr management works →The hard roles are experienced engagement managers, senior consultants who can lead a client room, and research staff who can build a model quickly. We agree the grade expectations with the partners first, then write the role brief and the case or written exercise used in selection. Interviews follow a set question list with a scoring sheet that each panel member fills in before the group compares notes. Analysts who plan to study again are discussed honestly at offer stage, so expectations about early exits are open on both sides.
What you receive
An example, not a client storySuppose a firm needs a senior consultant to lead a client team at short notice. Instead of asking whoever a partner knows, a role brief and case exercise are written, three candidates are scored on the same sheet, and the partners compare notes only after every panel member has marked independently.
How the recruitment for permanent roles works →Manager sessions cover briefing a team at project start, giving written feedback at the end of an engagement and handling a consultant who is struggling at a client site. Partners are coached on how to hold a staffing conversation and a promotion conversation. Analysts and consultants get shorter sessions on filling timesheets daily, claiming expenses on time and asking for development. Each session uses sanitised cases from the firm's own engagements, with a practice round and a one-page takeaway, so newly promoted managers have language ready for their first team.
What you receive
An example, not a client storyPicture a senior consultant promoted to engagement manager who has never written feedback for a junior. A workshop gives the new manager a feedback form, a practice conversation built on a past engagement, and a checklist for the first team briefing, so the first project in charge starts with a plan.
How the manager and team training works →The handbook is written around how consulting staff really work: travel weeks, client-site conduct, confidentiality of client material, timesheet discipline, expenses and the grade grid. We draft each policy in plain language and have it read by a partner and a manager before release. Employment and confidentiality wording is confirmed by the firm's own adviser. We then set up HR software to hold grade records, allocation history, appraisal notes, leave and claims, so partners and finance staff look at the same record instead of separate spreadsheets.
What you receive
An example, not a client storySay a consultant on a client site asks whether a client-paid flight can be claimed again. Today nobody is sure. With a written travel note and claim records in the system, the answer sits on one page, the same for partner and analyst, and finance can see the claim without chasing an email chain.
How the policies, handbook and hr software works →Yes. We write a fortnightly allocation meeting where partners and managers review upcoming engagements, bench time and development needs together, with a short log of what was decided and why. The aim is a visible process, not a rule that removes partner judgement. Any employment point about assignment or notice is confirmed by your own adviser.
Some exits are planned from the day a person joins, so we do not promise to stop them. What we set up is a clear grade grid, a feedback talk at the end of each engagement and an honest conversation at offer stage, so planned exits are expected and unplanned ones can be traced to a cause.
We make the entry short, a few lines against an engagement code, and add a weekly manager check so guesses are spotted. We also look at what slows entries at client sites, such as access or unclear codes. Utilisation figures then rest on the real week, and invoices follow the same record, so managers argue less about gaps.
Yes. We write one note on class of travel, allowances, claim timing and what happens when a client pays, and apply it to partners and analysts alike. Your adviser confirms the tax and employment treatment of allowances. We do not process claims or payroll, but we set up the record so claims are followed through.
GullyHR runs talent acquisition for permanent roles in management consulting. For each role we agree the job description with you, find and screen candidates against it, and support the offer through to joining. Tell us the role and the number of people, and we start there.
We recruit permanent employees. We do not supply contract or temporary staff.
Between engagements, consultants wait for allocation. Long gaps hurt margin and morale, and the partners hardly see them until a new proposal lands.
Allocation follows personal preference. Some consultants get every good engagement, while others sit on weak ones with no development.
Hours entered on Friday for the week are rough. Invoices and utilisation numbers rest on them, and managers argue over the gaps.
Consultants spend Monday to Thursday at client sites and claim expenses late. Policies on class of travel and allowance are not applied evenly.
What separates a consultant from a senior consultant is vague, so promotion rounds produce disappointment and exits.
Some join planning to study again or move to a client's strategy team, so exits at the two to three year mark are expected and costly.
Start with the topics that matter most here: Organisation Design; HR Analytics and Management Reporting; Career and Succession Management. Then work through the rest. Each topic is written for professional services, not in general.
Structure, reporting lines and who is allowed to decide what.
A short monthly pack management actually reads.
Named backups for the roles that cannot be vacant.
How many people, in which roles, by when, and what they will cost.
Requisition to joining, the same way every time.
A first day that is the same for the fifth joiner as the first.
Records, attendance, leave and the day-to-day HR that must simply work.
Salary structure, payroll inputs and a month that closes on time.
Goals, reviews and ratings that hold up in a conversation.
Training planned from need rather than from the calendar.
Communication, recognition and the conditions people actually work in.
Two routes, one for complaints, one for conduct, kept separate.
Policies a manager can apply, and obligations with owners and dates.
Induction, records, incident reporting and follow-through.
Who leaves, when, why, and which of them mattered.
Resignation to relieving letter, in a defined order.
Records that survive people, and approvals that do not queue.
An HR function that runs the same way every month.
The pieces a management consulting business puts in place, in an order that makes each easier. Open any card for the detail.
Clear skills for analyst, consultant, senior consultant and manager, with examples of work at each level.
Clear skills for analyst, consultant, senior consultant and manager, with examples of work at each level. The competency work builds it.
Partners and managers review upcoming engagements, bench time and development needs together, so staffing is not left to chance.
Partners and managers review upcoming engagements, bench time and development needs together, so staffing is not left to chance.
A few lines each day against an engagement code, with a weekly manager check.
A few lines each day against an engagement code, with a weekly manager check. Utilisation then reflects the real week. See reporting and analytics.
Class of travel, allowances, claim timing and what happens when a client pays.
Class of travel, allowances, claim timing and what happens when a client pays. Applied the same way for partners and analysts.
A short, written talk between the manager and each team member, so appraisals do not rest on memory.
A short, written talk between the manager and each team member, so appraisals do not rest on memory.
Spot the managers who could become principals and give them a path to business development.
Spot the managers who could become principals and give them a path to business development. See succession planning.
Confirm with a qualified professional. What applies to you depends on your business, your state and your arrangements, and it changes. This page describes practice. It does not state a legal position.
Grade definitions and skills lists that make promotion and staffing decisions easier to explain.
A weekly view of utilisation, bench time and exits by team and engagement.
Campus and lateral hiring plans for analysts and managers that follow the sales pipeline.
A route for strong managers to become principals, with business development skills added along the way.
Start with a free conversation, or see the paid HR Diagnostic.
Understand the business, its workforce, current processes and HR challenges.
Find the missing, weak, inconsistent or person-dependent processes.
Create the structure, processes, policies, SOPs, dashboards and systems needed.
Help HR and department managers actually adopt the new system.
Digitise repetitive and approval-based workflows where it is worth doing.
Track hiring, attendance, employee cost, performance, training and attrition.
Strengthen the people-management system continuously, not once.
From the GullyHR blog: one on HR in professional services, and one on each of the topics this page points to.

Why associates and managers leave consulting, accounting, legal and advisory firms, and how to ask about progression, workload and partners at exit.
6 min readRead article
A founder's guide to building job grades, titles and billing levels for a growing IT services firm, with a step-by-step method and a grade description outline.
6 min readRead article
Six numbers, one page, same format each month. What they are, how to define them so they mean the same thing twice, and what each one tells you.
8 min readRead article
A two-hour exercise that names the roles you could not fill quickly, who could cover them, and what readiness would actually require.
7 min readRead articleMore on the GullyHR blog.
Review upcoming work every fortnight, use bench time for proposals, research and training, and plan hiring against the sales pipeline. Look at how long people wait and why, then fix the biggest cause.
A small group of partners and managers meeting regularly, using a shared view of skills and availability. It keeps allocation fair, and gives each consultant a chance at a range of work.
Short daily entries against agreed engagement codes, checked weekly by the manager. Long, late entries are guesses, and guessed hours distort both invoices and the picture of how people are used.
Give them exposure early, a clear route to the next grade and a manager who coaches. Some will still leave for study or industry, so keep in touch with them as alumni.
Yes, a plain one. Settle class of travel, allowances and claim timing once and apply it to everyone. It avoids small arguments each trip and stops the feeling that partners play by other rules.
We would list who is on the bench, compare timesheets with what managers say people did and ask consultants what separates their grade from the next. A competency grid and a fortnightly allocation meeting are good first jobs. Scope is written down for your approval.
All 7 business types in management & business consulting firms · Find another business type
See all HR topics for professional services, or another industry.
Tell us your industry, team size and the issue you want to address. Bring one example of where work gets delayed or ownership is unclear, and the deadline or decision you are working towards.