Industries
Why agency employees leave and how to understand why
Creatives, planners and account teams leave for reasons beyond pay. How to run an exit conversation in an agency, spot patterns by account and act on them.
7 min readRead article
Marketing, Advertising and Creative
HR for Publishing Companies: Editors, Writers and Production Teams
A publishing company turns writing into books, magazines or digital content on a calendar of deadlines. Here is how to run editors, freelancers and production staff.
Not sure what you need? Tell us about your business in six short steps and we will come to the first meeting prepared.
Share your requirementsHow the work is organised
A publishing company acquires or commissions content and brings it to readers as books, magazines, newspapers, journals or digital titles. Its staff include commissioning and copy editors, writers and reporters, designers, production and print managers, marketing and sales staff, and distribution teams. A large share of the work is done by freelancers: translators, proofreaders, illustrators and indexers. Every title or issue follows a schedule from manuscript to print or release, and one late step moves everything after it. Pay in the industry is often modest, and many people stay because they care about the work. See also HR for marketing and creative agencies.
Who does the work
- Commissioning and acquisitions editors
- Copy editors and proofreaders
- Writers and reporters
- Designers and typesetters
- Production and print managers
- Marketing and publicity staff
- Sales and distribution staff
- Rights and contracts staff
- Freelance translators and illustrators
Where HR strains in publishing companies
Deadlines slide down the chain
A late manuscript delays editing, design and printing, and production staff absorb the pressure with long hours near the end.
Freelancers are managed informally
Commissions, fees and deadlines sit in emails, and payments are late or disputed, which damages relationships with good freelancers.
Pay is low for the skill
Editors and designers could earn more elsewhere, and the company relies on passion until a better offer arrives.
Editorial and commercial teams disagree
Editors want quality and the sales team wants titles that sell, and without a clear process each decision becomes a quarrel.
Print-run seasons create peaks
Book fairs, academic terms and festival seasons compress work, and staffing is not planned around them.
Roles are narrow and careers unclear
An editorial assistant rarely sees how to become an editor, and good people leave to move up.
Print and digital skills diverge
Staff trained for print struggle with digital formats and analytics, and nobody has planned their learning.
What a working HR set-up looks like
- 01
Put freelance engagements on paper
A standard commission note with scope, fee, deadline and payment date, and a single place to track who owes what. HR documentation shows how to keep it consistent.
- 02
Work backwards from the production calendar
A shared schedule that shows each title's stages and who holds them, so slippage appears early and peak weeks are staffed.
- 03
Create career ladders in editorial and production
Defined steps from assistant to senior editor or production manager with the skills for each. Role design helps.
- 04
Set up a title approval process
A simple meeting and a set of criteria where editorial, sales and finance decide together, which reduces later conflict.
- 05
Plan digital skill building
Short training in formats, analytics and tools for print-trained staff, using the learning and development process.
What to put in place first
- List every freelancer paid last quarter, what was agreed and when they were paid.
- Mark the three busiest weeks of the year and who works them.
- Ask an editorial assistant what they think the next step in their career is.
- Review how the last difficult title decision was made and by whom.
- Check which staff have used digital tools and analytics and which have not.
- Confirm with a qualified professional the employment, freelancer-engagement and intellectual-property obligations that apply to your publishing business.
Confirm with a qualified professional. What applies to you depends on your business, your state and your arrangements, and it changes. This page describes practice. It does not state a legal position.
Where GullyHR helps
- HR documentation process
Standard letters and notes for staff and freelancers so terms are clear from the start.
- Role design and job descriptions
Defined steps and skills from assistant to senior roles in editorial, design and production.
- Learning and development process
A plan to build digital and format skills in a team trained for print.
- Compensation benchmarking
A view of how your pay compares for editorial and production roles, and where small changes help most.
Every engagement starts by recording where you stand, and every later report compares against that. We do not promise outcomes. Start with a free conversation, or see the paid HR Diagnostic.
Blogs worth reading first
From the GullyHR blog: one on HR in marketing, advertising and creative, and one on each of the topics this page points to.
HR Process
A grievance procedure for a company with no HR department
An employee brings you a complaint about their supervisor. What happens next should not depend on who is in the room. A grievance procedure a small company can actually run.
8 min readRead article
HR Management
"What if this person resigned tomorrow?" A succession exercise for small companies
A two-hour exercise that names the roles you could not fill quickly, who could cover them, and what readiness would actually require.
7 min readRead article
HR Management
Salary bands for SMEs: building grades when you have never had any
Most salary structures grew one negotiation at a time. How to build grades and bands from what you already pay, without repricing everybody at once.
8 min readRead articleMore on the GullyHR blog.
Questions owners ask
Agree scope, fee, deadline and payment date in writing before the work starts, pay on the agreed day and keep a simple tracker. Reliable payment is what keeps good freelancers.
Show the schedule to everyone, flag slippage early and set a cut-off for late changes. Fewer last-minute edits reduces the crunch more than extra staff.
Offer a clear career step, real responsibility, recognition and fair review each year. Low pay is more tolerable when people can see progress.
Use a regular acquisition meeting with shared criteria and recorded decisions. People accept outcomes better when they understand the basis.
A few things matter early: written terms for staff and freelancers, leave and attendance records and a path for resolving disagreements. They keep a small team stable.
We would look at who the freelancers are and what was agreed with each, who works the busiest weeks of the production calendar, and where editorial assistants see their next step. A sensible first piece of work is putting freelance engagements on paper and drafting a simple career ladder for editorial. Scope follows in writing, so you can accept or trim it.
More on HR for marketing, advertising and creative
All 3 business types in marketing, advertising and creative · Find another business type
Radio and broadcast stationsSign and printing companiesEmployee Relations in marketing, advertising and creativeCareer and Succession Management in marketing, advertising and creativeCompensation, Payroll and Benefits in marketing, advertising and creative
See all HR topics for marketing, advertising and creative, or another industry.