Skip to main content
GullyHR

Free template

Probation review checklist

Use this at the midpoint and at the end of probation so the confirmation decision rests on notes, not on memory.

Download for WordFree. No sign-up.
Workplace scene for Probation review checklist

Before the review

  • The employee's written goals for probation are to hand.
  • Attendance and leave record for the period.
  • Notes from check-ins with the manager since joining.
  • Any feedback from colleagues the employee worked with.

Assess each area

AreaWhat good looks likeEvidenceRating (1 to 5)
Role knowledgeDoes the core tasks of the role without being re-taught  
Quality and accuracyWork needs few corrections  
ReliabilityMeets deadlines, keeps commitments  
CommunicationAsks, updates and escalates at the right time  
TeamworkWorks well across the team  
Attendance and conductWithin policy  

The conversation

  • Share the ratings and evidence before the meeting, not for the first time in it.
  • Ask the employee how they see the first months and what would help.
  • Agree two or three things for the next period, in writing.

Decision

  • Confirm from [Date].
  • Extend probation by [Number] months, with the specific goals that must be met.
  • Do not confirm. Follow the notice terms in the appointment letter.

Record

Manager: ______________ Employee: ______________ HR: ______________ Date: ____________

Keep a signed copy on the employee's file and give the employee a copy of the outcome.

A starting point, not legal advice. Check the final wording against your contracts and the rules of your state, and have a qualified professional review it before you issue it.

How to use this template

  1. The reporting manager fills the assessment before the review meeting, using notes from the probation period.
  2. HR sends the form to the manager a few weeks before the probation end date so there is time to act.
  3. Hold the conversation face to face. Share the ratings and examples, and let the employee respond.
  4. Record the decision, the reasons and any agreed targets on the form. Both sides sign.
  5. File the form in the employee record and hand the decision to HR for the letter.
  6. Review the criteria each year so they still match what the role really needs.

A filled example (illustrative)

This example is invented for illustration. Replace every value with your own.

AreaRatingEvidence
Quality of workMeetsTwo reports needed corrections, none repeated
Attendance and punctualityMeetsNo unplanned absence
Learning the processExceedsHandled month-end entries alone from week ten
TeamworkNeeds improvementLate sharing of updates with the sales team
DecisionConfirm with targetsShare updates daily; review again after one month

Common mistakes

  • Doing the review on the last day, with no time to extend, coach or plan for an exit.
  • Rating on general feeling and not on examples from the employee's actual work.
  • Letting the manager skip the conversation and only sending the outcome letter.
  • Confirming everyone by default because nobody filled the form on time.
  • Not recording the extension reason, so the extension looks arbitrary later.

Adapt it to your business

  • Factory: rate skill on the machine or line, safety behaviour and adherence to the shift plan.
  • Shop: rate customer handling, cash and stock accuracy, and punctuality for opening and closing.
  • Clinic: rate patient communication, record keeping and following clinical protocols.
  • Office: rate output quality, ownership of tasks and how the person works with other teams.

Questions about this template

Only if your appointment letter allows it. State the reason, the new end date and the targets in writing. Confirm the final wording with a qualified adviser.

Start with your business need

What does your HR team need to solve?

Tell us your industry, team size and the issue you want to address. Bring one example of where work gets delayed or ownership is unclear, and the deadline or decision you are working towards.

  • A free first conversation with an HR practitioner
  • A clear scope and fee before any paid work
  • A practical next step for your business

Let’s start with your business

Share your contact details and the HR challenge on your mind. We’ll help you find the right starting point.

Include your country code, for example +44 or +1. Indian numbers can be 10 digits.

Your details stay private. Privacy policy