Skip to main content
GullyHR

Free template

Interview scorecard template

Fill in the competencies before the first interview, score each candidate on the same sheet, and compare notes only after everyone has scored. Adapt the competencies and scale to each role, and have your hiring rules reviewed where they affect employment terms.

Download for WordFree. No sign-up.
Workplace scene for Interview scorecard template

Interview details

Candidate: ____________ Position: ____________ Requisition no.: ____________

Interviewer: ____________ Round: [1 / 2 / 3] Date: ________ Mode: [In person / Video / Phone]

Before the interview

  • Choose four to six competencies from the job requisition, with at least two on role skills and two on behaviour.
  • Write the question you will ask for each competency, and one follow-up.
  • Read the CV and note what you want to check.
  • Decide who covers which competency across the panel so questions are not repeated.

Scorecard

CompetencyWhat good looks likeQuestion askedEvidence from the answerScore (1 to 5)
[Role skill 1][Describe]   
[Role skill 2][Describe]   
Problem solvingBreaks the problem down and explains the choice made   
CommunicationClear, to the point, listens before answering   
OwnershipGives examples where they followed through without being chased   
Fit with how we work[Describe, for example comfort with shift work or customer contact]   

Rating scale

Score the answer, not the person. Write what the candidate said or did as evidence. Do not record or score age, marital status, religion, caste, health or family plans.

  • 1: No evidence of the competency, or evidence against it.
  • 2: Some evidence, but below what the role needs.
  • 3: Meets what the role needs.
  • 4: Clearly strong, with specific examples.
  • 5: Exceptional, can coach others.

Overall recommendation

Main strengths: ____________

Main concerns, and what we would still need to check: ____________

Compensation expectation and notice period noted: ____________

Interviewer signature: ____________ Date: ____________

Share your scores with the hiring manager before the panel discussion. Keep the signed scorecards with the requisition for [number] months.

  • Strong yes
  • Yes
  • No
  • Strong no

A starting point, not legal advice. Check the final wording against your contracts and the rules of your state, and have a qualified professional review it before you issue it.

How to use this template

  1. HR and the hiring manager agree four to six skills and traits before the first interview.
  2. Each interviewer reads the scorecard and prepares questions for their assigned areas.
  3. Score during or right after each interview, not at the end of the day or week.
  4. Write one line of evidence beside each score. A number alone does not help.
  5. Compare scorecards in a short debrief. Discuss gaps and then decide.
  6. Keep scorecards with the requisition for the period your policy says. Review the criteria after each hire.

A filled example (illustrative)

This example is invented for illustration. Replace every value with your own.

CriterionScore (1 to 5)Evidence
Role skills4Explained month-end close steps correctly
Problem solving3Needed hints on reconciliation question
Communication4Clear and brief answers
Fit with team3Prefers working alone, role needs coordination
RecommendationProceed to next roundInterviewer A

Common mistakes

  • Changing the criteria between candidates, which makes comparison unfair.
  • Discussing the candidate with other interviewers before scoring, which biases the scores.
  • Rating only on likeability, not on evidence of skills for the role.
  • Asking about marital status, family plans or religion. Keep to job-related questions.
  • Losing the sheets, so there is no record when a candidate asks why they were not selected.

Adapt it to your business

  • Factory: add a practical test or trade demonstration, and a safety awareness check.
  • Shop: add a role play on customer handling and a basic billing or counting check.
  • Clinic: add verification of licence, plus a scenario on patient handling.
  • Office: add a short work sample, such as a report, a draft email or a spreadsheet task.

Questions about this template

They make comparison easier, but only when each number has a written reason.

Start with your business need

What does your HR team need to solve?

Tell us your industry, team size and the issue you want to address. Bring one example of where work gets delayed or ownership is unclear, and the deadline or decision you are working towards.

  • A free first conversation with an HR practitioner
  • A clear scope and fee before any paid work
  • A practical next step for your business

Let’s start with your business

Share your contact details and the HR challenge on your mind. We’ll help you find the right starting point.

Include your country code, for example +44 or +1. Indian numbers can be 10 digits.

Your details stay private. Privacy policy