Hiring: is there a repeatable way from request to offer?
Is there an approved role request and a job description? Do interviewers use the same questions? Is the reason for each hire written down? Who approves the offer, and is the offer letter kept?
HR audit · Building maintenance companies
An HR audit checklist is a list of questions that tests whether each part of your people management works in practice: hiring, onboarding, records, policies, pay process, leave and attendance, performance, exits and grievance handling. Answer them honestly from real files. Gaps show where to fix first. GullyHR also runs a paid outside HR audit when you want an independent review.

The operating context
A building maintenance company keeps lifts, pumps, electrics, plumbing and air conditioning running at client premises. It sells availability, and the owner's challenge is rostering trained technicians, covering night calls and keeping skills current across trades.

Assign an evidence owner and sample period to each applicable checklist item instead of accepting a tick as proof that a process works. Workforce to consider: Electricians and panel technicians, Plumbers and pump operators, HVAC and chiller technicians.
Completed checklist, source documents and unresolved-item register. A workforce issue to consider: Who attended, what was done and what part was used is written on paper or not at all, so repeat faults are argued about.
Mark an item as not applicable only with an explanation; separate unverified answers from confirmed gaps.
The right workforce and approval structure depends on the operations you run. Confirm which of these apply, and whether they share one HR process.
Work through the nine areas one at a time. For each, pull the real documents, pick the last two or three cases, and answer the questions below with yes, partly or no, writing a line of evidence beside each answer. Mark the partly and no answers, then rank them by how much harm a failure would cause and how easy the fix is. That ranked list is your first improvement plan. Copy the layout in the sample below into one sheet tab per area, so the checklist stays the same shape as the paid audit. If the answers expose areas where you cannot judge the quality yourself, an outside review fills that gap. GullyHR offers that as a paid HR audit, and the checklist helps you prepare for it.
Is there an approved role request and a job description? Do interviewers use the same questions? Is the reason for each hire written down? Who approves the offer, and is the offer letter kept?
Is there a joining checklist with an owner? Are documents collected before or on joining? Does each new person know their manager, their goals and the main policies? Is there a check-in after the first weeks?
Is there one file per person with offer, address and identity documents, role changes and warnings? Who can see it? Is it paper, sheet or system, and is there a copy? What happens to it after someone leaves?
Which policies exist, and when were they last read by a person who is not their author? Do employees acknowledge them? Do managers apply them the same way? Where there is no policy, what is the unwritten rule?
Who sends inputs for attendance, leave, joiners, leavers and changes, and by when? Who checks the output before it is paid? Where is the approval kept? How are pay questions from employees answered?
Where is leave applied for and approved? Do balances match the policy? How are late marks, absences and shift changes recorded? Who reconciles before pay inputs are sent?
Are goals set? Are reviews held on schedule for everyone? Do ratings link to any decision on pay, promotion or support? Is there a written plan when performance falls short?
Is there a resignation record, a handover list and an exit conversation? Are assets and access recovered? Is final pay handled by a defined step? Are exit reasons looked at together?
Is there a stated route for complaints, and a person or group who hears them? Are complaints logged and closed with a written outcome? Do managers know what to do when someone raises one?
Agree the locations, period and sample. Walk through completed and exceptional cases with the owners, compare records with the stated process and distinguish missing evidence from ineffective controls.
Collect offer letters, the policy folder, the leave and attendance record, last cycle's pay inputs, appraisal forms, exit files and any complaint log. Missing files are themselves an answer.
For each area choose the last two or three actual cases, such as the last hire, the last exit and the last complaint. Test the questions against these, not against what the policy says should happen.
Mark each question yes, partly or no, and write where the evidence sits. If you cannot find it in a few minutes, record that.
Score each gap for harm if it fails and ease of fixing. High harm and easy fix go first.
Assign each gap to an owner. Mark the ones that need a policy written, a process designed, software, or an outside view.
Review factual accuracy with the owners, prioritise findings by impact and urgency, and record who accepts each action. A maturity score is used only where the criteria and evidence are agreed.
Share personal records only after the scope, access and handling arrangements are agreed.
The client owns employee records and approves policies, spending and employment decisions. GullyHR's assigned responsibilities are documented in the engagement.
These are measures to track against your baseline, not promised results. Agree definitions, record sources and review dates at the start.
A spreadsheet is enough: one tab per area, columns for the question, the answer, the evidence and the owner. GullyHR software can later hold employee records, leave, attendance and pay inputs in one place, but the checklist does not need it.
Read the full HR audit checklist for growing businesses service guide →
Use this page on your own. No contact with GullyHR is needed.
A paid, evidence-based outside review of how your HR runs, with ranked findings and a sequenced plan. The first conversation is free.
A paid review of hiring only, for companies whose main worry is how they select people.
Limit access to the records needed for the agreed work. Confirm authorised users, secure sharing, retention and return or deletion arrangements before exchanging personal information.
Applicability depends on locations, workforce arrangements and the issue under review. Confirm applicable requirements with your qualified adviser before adopting policies or employment actions; this service is not a legal certification.
Employment-law opinions, statutory filings, professional or clinical standards and safety-critical technical decisions require the appropriate qualified professional; include those dependencies in the scope.
For building maintenance companies, identify who owns these records: completed checklist, source documents and unresolved-item register. Start with an anonymised example and the decision you need to make; agree the sample and access before sharing personal data.
An HR audit checks how your people processes work in practice. This checklist groups them into nine areas: hiring, onboarding, records, policies, pay process, leave and attendance, performance, exits and grievance handling. For each, it asks what exists, who owns it and whether the last real case followed it.
For a small team with files in reach, a first pass can be quick. What decides the time is headcount, how many locations keep their own records, how scattered the files are and whether the person who knows each process is free to answer. Chasing missing documents is the slowest part.
No. It tests whether your HR runs in an orderly way, not whether you meet any specific law. GullyHR does not give legal advice or compliance support. Ask your own qualified adviser which statutory duties apply to your business.
Whoever holds the files: the founder, HR lead or office manager. If answers differ between them, note both. Disagreement about how a process works is itself a finding.
Share your workforce size, locations, the part of HR audit checklist for growing businesses you need and one issue you want to resolve. Do not attach identifiable employee or candidate records to the initial enquiry; access and handling are agreed later.
Tell us the teams and locations involved, what is happening today and what you want this work to resolve.
Tell us your industry, team size and the issue you want to address. Bring one example of where work gets delayed or ownership is unclear, and the deadline or decision you are working towards.