Skip to main content
GullyHR

HR management consulting · Antique and curio dealers

Performance Improvement Plans and Corrective Feedback for Antique and curio dealers

A performance improvement plan is a short written agreement that names a gap in an employee's work, the standard expected, the support offered and the review date. Corrective feedback is the conversation that comes before it. GullyHR designs this route for startups and small and medium businesses: the diagnosis step, the conversation planner, the plan format, check-in log and manager briefing. Your legal adviser checks the wording.

A manager and employee having a constructive performance review with a shared notebook.

The operating context

Make the improvement expectation observable

An antique and curio dealer buys and sells old furniture, brass, coins, paintings and collectables to collectors and decorators. It rests on a few people who can judge an object, remember who owns what, and be trusted with items that have no price tag.

Shop managers or senior salespeopleAppraisal and buying assistantsRestorers and polishersHandlers and packersCataloguing and photography staffAccounts and consignment clerks
A retail store manager briefing sales and checkout colleagues before opening

The decision to work through

Describe the performance gap, required standard, support, review dates and evidence with the employee's manager. Workforce to consider: Shop managers or senior salespeople, Appraisal and buying assistants, Restorers and polishers.

Records to prepare

Written improvement plan, support commitments and review notes. A workforce issue to consider: A manager who knows serious collectors may take them to a new shop or sell directly. With no agreement on notice or conduct, the dealer has little recourse.

An exception to test

Test a missed milestone alongside whether agreed support was supplied; any employment action remains a separate authorised decision.

Which parts of your business should the scope cover?

The right workforce and approval structure depends on the operations you run. Confirm which of these apply, and whether they share one HR process.

  • Antique furniture and carved wood dealers
  • Brass, bronze and temple artefact dealers
  • Old coin, stamp and banknote dealers
  • Vintage poster, radio, camera and gramophone sellers
  • Colonial and heritage home decor dealers
  • Textile, saree and tribal jewellery antique dealers

When to consider this service

  • A manager has been unhappy with someone for a year, but nothing was ever said or written down.
  • The first formal step an employee sees is a warning letter, and they say they were never told.
  • Managers label people as lazy or careless instead of describing what happened and when.
  • A plan is written to push someone out, and the employee can tell, so the whole team loses trust.

Businesses this service is designed for

  • Founders who have never issued a plan and want a fair standard before the first case.
  • HR heads in growing companies whose managers handle shortfalls in very different ways.
  • Companies where the first sign of trouble is a resignation or a dispute.
  • Business heads preparing to make a hard decision and wanting the file to be complete.

Decisions this work supports

GullyHR builds a staged route for handling underperformance. We begin by agreeing, with the owner, when a conversation is enough and when a written plan is needed. Managers then learn to describe what happened in plain, dated terms, and to check the real cause: knowledge, method, motivation or support from the organisation. Where the skill is missing, the answer may be training or a different role, not a plan. For a recurring or serious gap we draft a plan format with the baseline, target, standard, support, weekly check-in dates and a signature box that records the employee's own comments. We set the rules for who drafts, who reviews and who signs, and how the end decision is recorded. Finally we brief managers and test the route on live cases, with your adviser reviewing the final documents.

A diagnosis of the real cause comes before any plan is written.

Managers use a short gap analysis to separate knowledge, method, motivation and support problems, and to note what the employee did not control. The action chosen must match the cause.

Corrective conversations are planned, private and held within days.

A planner sheet turns the behaviour into a dated fact, checks that it can be changed, sets the opening, and records the alternative agreed and the follow-up date after two to four weeks.

The improvement plan has a fixed format with measurable items.

Each item carries a baseline, a target and the standard it is judged against. The plan also lists support, check-in dates, the review date and what happens if the gap closes or does not.

The employee has a voice in the plan and in the record.

The format has space for the employee's comments and acknowledgement. We set a route for asking for a second view from a senior manager or HR before the end decision.

Records are kept to a standard that a reviewer could follow.

We define what goes in a case file: fact sheet, plan, check-in notes, outcome form. Managers are told what to avoid writing, such as guesses about character, health or family matters.

Plans are kept apart from discipline and from retaliation.

We write the line between a plan about performance and a process about conduct, and require HR to confirm that no plan follows a complaint or a leave request without a second review.

Diagnose, compare options and decide

Establish the management decision, constraints and evidence. Compare feasible options with the accountable leaders, including affordability, employee impact and implementation dependencies.

  1. 01

    Agree the escalation ladder

    With the owner we decide the steps from informal word to conversation, plan and outcome decision, and who may start each one. We write the ladder on one page.

  2. 02

    Set the diagnosis step

    We introduce the gap analysis sheet and run it on two recent cases. Managers practise writing the gap as a dated fact and rating the four possible causes.

  3. 03

    Draft the plan format

    We build the plan template with items, baselines, targets, support, check-in dates, comments and signature fields, then fit it to your roles and your tone.

  4. 04

    Brief the managers

    A working session covers the conversation planner, role play of an opening, what to write in the file and what to leave out. Managers leave with a worked example.

  5. 05

    Test on live cases

    Over a few weeks we review the first plans and conversations with HR, correct gaps in the notes and tighten the wording of items that cannot be measured.

  6. 06

    Audit and hand over

    We sample recent warnings and plans for consistency, help given and record quality, report the gaps found, and hand over the final templates and the case file index.

Record the chosen option, the decision owner and the measures to review. Revisit the framework when workforce needs or operating assumptions change.

Management frameworks and decision support

  • Escalation ladder for underperformance, on one page
  • Performance gap analysis sheet with four cause ratings
  • Difficult-conversation planner and fact sheet
  • Performance improvement plan template with employee comments section
  • Weekly check-in log and a signed outcome decision form for each plan
  • Case file index listing what to keep and what never to write
  • Manager briefing deck with a worked example and role play scripts
  • Review note on a sample of recent cases, with fixes listed

What your team provides

  • The owner decides how firm each step is and who may start it.
  • Managers write each case with real dates, data and support offered.
  • Managers hold the meetings and HR reviews the log before the end date.
  • Your own qualified legal adviser reviews them and decides any statutory question.
  • The company decides the outcome of each case and communicates it.

Share personal records only after the scope, access and handling arrangements are agreed.

Responsibilities and approvals

The client owns employee records and approves policies, spending and employment decisions. GullyHR's assigned responsibilities are documented in the engagement.

Writing the escalation ladder for underperformance

GullyHR
We draft the steps, roles and sign-off points for your review.
Your team
The owner decides how firm each step is and who may start it.

Diagnosis and the content of each plan

GullyHR
We provide the sheets and coach managers on writing gaps and targets.
Your team
Managers write each case with real dates, data and support offered.

Running check-ins and recording the outcome

GullyHR
We set the cadence and the form for logging each meeting.
Your team
Managers hold the meetings and HR reviews the log before the end date.

Legal and statutory review of the documents

GullyHR
We draft the documents and flag where wording needs a second look.
Your team
Your own qualified legal adviser reviews them and decides any statutory question.

Decisions on the outcome of each case

GullyHR
We run the route and review the file on request.
Your team
The company decides the outcome of each case and communicates it.

Outputs to review at handover

Review these outputs with your process owner and agree the evidence required for sign-off.

  • Escalation ladder for underperformance, on one page
  • Performance gap analysis sheet with four cause ratings
  • Difficult-conversation planner and fact sheet
  • Performance improvement plan template with employee comments section
  • Weekly check-in log and a signed outcome decision form for each plan
  • Case file index listing what to keep and what never to write
  • Manager briefing deck with a worked example and role play scripts
  • Review note on a sample of recent cases, with fixes listed

Tools and implementation dependencies

The templates are editable documents kept in a shared folder you control, with a case file index and a simple tracking sheet for open plans and check-in dates. If you already use an HR system, we adapt the forms to fit it. Our own software is optional and is never needed to run the route. Access to case files should be limited to HR and the managers involved.

Read the full performance improvement plans and corrective feedback service guide →

Agree the engagement before work starts.

Plan and conversation starter pack

A focused piece: the gap analysis, the conversation planner and the plan template, with one briefing session for your managers.

Full route and briefing programme

The ladder, templates, manager briefing, support on early live cases and a closing review, delivered over a few months.

Review of cases you already hold

We read a sample of recent warnings and plans, report on consistency and record quality, and list fixes for the file and the habits behind it.

Alongside other HR work

Added to a performance management build, a manager development programme or your disciplinary and grievance documents, so all of them use one language.

Scope and exclusions

  • Management retains employment, organisation and spending decisions. The engagement supports those decisions; it does not automatically include daily HR administration or monthly payroll processing.
  • The case is about conduct, not performance; that belongs in your disciplinary and grievance route.
  • You want a letter issued or a case decided for you; we design the route and your managers run it.
  • Your managers have never given everyday feedback and need core people skills first.
  • You want a legal opinion on a specific case; that comes from your own adviser.
Confidentiality, specialist review and accountability

Limit access to the records needed for the agreed work. Confirm authorised users, secure sharing, retention and return or deletion arrangements before exchanging personal information.

Applicability depends on locations, workforce arrangements and the issue under review. Confirm applicable requirements with your qualified adviser before adopting policies or employment actions; this service is not a legal certification.

Employment-law opinions, statutory filings, professional or clinical standards and safety-critical technical decisions require the appropriate qualified professional; include those dependencies in the scope.

Questions before you decide

For antique and curio dealers, identify who owns these records: written improvement plan, support commitments and review notes. Start with an anonymised example and the decision you need to make; agree the sample and access before sharing personal data.

Discuss your priorities

Tell us the teams and locations involved, what is happening today and what you want this work to resolve.

Start with your business need

What does your HR team need to solve?

Tell us your industry, team size and the issue you want to address. Bring one example of where work gets delayed or ownership is unclear, and the deadline or decision you are working towards.

  • A free first conversation with an HR practitioner
  • A clear scope and fee before any paid work
  • A practical next step for your business

Let’s start with your business

Share your contact details and the HR challenge on your mind. We’ll help you find the right starting point.

Include your country code, for example +44 or +1. Indian numbers can be 10 digits.

Your details stay private. Privacy policy