Performance management and incentive design for Insurance companies: incentives that reward renewals and fair dealing, not only new business
Incentives shape how an insurer's people behave. Paying only on new business pulls attention from renewals, service and fair dealing, and sets branches against each other at year end.
Not sure what you need? Tell us about your business in six short steps and we will come to the first meeting prepared.
Share your requirementsWhy performance management and incentive design matters in insurance companies
Insurers run a sales incentive built on premium or policy count, paid monthly or quarterly. It is simple and it works for volume. It also rewards the sale of whatever is easiest, invites a year-end scramble and says nothing about whether the policy stays in force or the customer was well advised.
A balanced scheme adds renewal, quality and conduct measures for sales, and speed, accuracy and customer feedback for service and claims. It spreads payment across the year, uses team elements where branches share the work and explains how a month-end rating turns into pay. Fewer, clearer measures work better than a long list.
How to set it up
1. Choose measures by role
Sales: new business, renewals and policies in force. Service: turnaround and accuracy. Claims: decision time, quality of reasons and complaints. Pick two or three per role.
2. Set targets from data
Use territory potential and past results, not a flat uplift. Explain how targets were set so officers can see they are fair.
3. Spread payment across the year
Pay part of the incentive on a quarterly or annual cycle that includes renewals, so the final quarter is no longer a cliff.
4. Add a conduct gate
A serious complaint or breach of the company's selling rules reduces or removes the incentive. State the rule clearly and apply it evenly.
5. Review and adjust yearly
After each year, check which measures changed behaviour, what went unexpectedly well or badly, and adjust before the next cycle starts.
Check these first
Before changing anything, find out what is true today. Use your own records for a defined period and note gaps in the evidence. The review may take longer if records are incomplete or spread across teams.
- Read your incentive scheme and list the behaviours it rewards.
- Ask three officers whether they could calculate their own payout.
- Check how much of annual incentive falls in the last quarter.
- See whether service and claims staff have any measure at all.
GullyHR can do this with you. Read how we approach performance management and incentive design in general, or share your requirements and we will tell you where to start.
Questions owners ask
Be careful. Pay linked to rejecting claims can distort decisions. Use measures like turnaround, accuracy and complaint handling, with recognition rather than a payout tied to outcomes.
Enough to motivate and not so frequent that the year-end rush rules everything. A mix of monthly or quarterly payment with a year-end element tied to renewals works well.
Yes, where staff share customers and work. A small team element beside individual pay encourages cooperation. Keep it modest so strong individuals still feel their effort counts.
We set up the interview and hiring process for insurance companies
Every business interviews, but few have a written process that works the same way for every role and every interviewer. GullyHR designs yours, from the role brief to the offer, trains your managers to run it, and can run it for you on the roles you hand us.