Performance management process for Rural development NGOs: fair targets for field and block teams
A watershed worker cannot control the rain, and a livelihood officer cannot control the market. Performance management must measure effort and judgement as well as results that depend on others.
Not sure what you need? Tell us about your business in six short steps and we will come to the first meeting prepared.
Share your requirementsWhy performance management process matters in rural development NGOs
Donor frameworks arrive with indicators, such as households reached, groups formed or hectares covered. Staff are then set targets that copy those numbers. A bad rainfall year ruins the yield figure, yet the facilitator did the work. A good year makes a weak worker look strong. Staff soon learn that numbers are what matter and begin to shape them.
A fairer process sets targets in two parts. One is what the person does: visits made, trainings held, groups supported, quality of records. The other is what changes in the community, shown with notes on the weather, the market and other factors. Reviews happen twice a year, in conversation, with evidence. Feedback also comes from the community and peers, since the supervisor sees little of the work.
How to set it up
1. Agree activity and outcome goals
Three to five goals per person, with a mix of work done and change seen. Write them in plain language the facilitator can repeat to a village group.
2. Note the context
At each review, record the rainfall, price changes or other factors that helped or hurt. This protects honest workers and exposes weak ones.
3. Hold a mid-year and year-end talk
A one hour conversation with the coordinator, with evidence from logs, visits and community feedback. Both sides write down what they agreed.
4. Add peer and community input
Ask two peers and a few group leaders for short comments. Treat them as one input, not the only one.
5. Link to growth, not just pay
Use the review to choose who gets training, a bigger area or a coordinator role. The compensation work can then follow evidence.
Check these first
Before changing anything, find out what is true today. These take an afternoon and use your own records.
- Read three recent reviews and see whether they mention anything beyond the indicator numbers.
- Ask a facilitator how last year's targets were set and by whom.
- Check whether reviews took place for staff in remote blocks.
- Look for staff rewarded for numbers that looked good but did not match field reports.
GullyHR can do this with you. Read how we approach performance management process in general, or share your requirements and we will tell you where to start.
Questions owners ask
Use them as a reference, not a copy. Individual goals should reflect what the person controls, with the donor numbers as a team or programme measure.
Plan the review visit in advance, use phone calls for a mid-year check and gather input from peers and the community. Do not skip remote staff because of distance.
Note the cause in the review, judge the work done and agree what to adjust. Punishing weather or price swings drives honest people away and rewards creative reporting.